In a growing business, a few people often carry a large share of the knowledge, relationships, and leadership. Losing one of them can slow growth, disrupt customers, or complicate a future sale or succession. A key employee retention plan is a structured way to reward those people for staying and contributing over time.
This guide reviews common types of retention plans, the design choices involved, and the tax and legal rules that may apply. It is educational and is meant to help owners prepare questions for their advisors.
What Is a Key Employee Retention Plan?
A key employee retention plan is an arrangement that provides additional compensation to selected employees, usually tied to staying with the company for a period of time or meeting performance goals. Many of these plans include vesting, which means the employee earns the benefit gradually or only after a certain date.
Why owners consider retention plans
Continuity: Keeping experienced leaders in place during growth or a transition.
Succession readiness: Encouraging future leaders to stay through an ownership change.
Business value: Buyers may view a stable leadership team as a positive factor.
Competitive pay: Supplementing salary when cash is limited.
Common Types of Retention Plans
There are several ways to structure retention incentives. Each has different costs, tax effects, and administrative needs.
Stay bonuses
A stay bonus is a cash payment made if the employee remains through a specific date or event, such as the close of a sale. Stay bonuses are relatively simple and are often used for short-term needs.
Deferred bonus plans
The business commits to a future payment that vests over several years. If the employee leaves before vesting, the unvested amount may be forfeited.
Nonqualified deferred compensation
These plans allow a business to provide supplemental retirement or deferred pay to selected employees beyond what a qualified plan permits. They must follow Section 409A rules on timing of elections and distributions.
Phantom stock and stock appreciation rights
These plans give employees a cash benefit tied to the value or growth in value of the company, without transferring actual ownership. They can be useful for owners who want to share growth without diluting control.
Restricted stock or profits interests
Some businesses grant actual equity that vests over time. This creates true ownership, which may affect voting, distributions, and future transactions.
Executive bonus and split-dollar arrangements
Some plans use life insurance as a benefit or funding source for key employees. These arrangements have specific tax rules and should be reviewed with qualified professionals.
Design Choices to Think Through
The details of a plan determine whether it supports your goals.
Who is eligible: Plans can be limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees.
Vesting schedule: Cliff vesting pays after a set period, while graded vesting earns the benefit gradually.
Performance measures: Some plans tie payments to revenue, profit, or individual goals.
Triggering events: Retirement, a sale of the business, death, or disability may affect payouts.
Forfeiture provisions: Rules for what happens if an employee leaves early or joins a competitor.
Funding approach: Some businesses set aside assets informally, while others pay from future cash flow.
Tax and Legal Considerations
Retention plans can raise tax and legal questions for both the business and the employee.
Timing of deductions: The business generally deducts deferred compensation when it is paid and included in the employee's income.
Section 409A: Nonqualified deferred compensation must meet strict rules, and failures can create penalties for the employee.
ERISA: Some plans may be subject to reporting or disclosure rules unless an exemption applies.
Employment agreements: Non-compete and non-solicitation terms are governed by state law, and Minnesota generally prohibits non-compete agreements entered into on or after July 1, 2023, with limited exceptions.
Because these rules are technical, owners often work with an attorney and tax professional when drafting a plan.
Connecting Retention to Succession and Exit Planning
A retention plan can be part of a larger ownership strategy. If you expect to sell the business or pass it to family, keeping key people through the transition may support continuity. Retention plans can also be coordinated with buy-sell agreements and key person insurance.
Ballast Advisors' small business planning addresses key employees through recruitment, retention, HR consulting, and incentive design, along with executive compensation, business succession, and qualified and non-qualified retirement plans. Explore the Ballast Advisors services page for details.
Measuring Whether a Plan Is Working
After a plan is in place, owners may want to review whether it is meeting its goals. Useful measures can include turnover among covered employees, how often employees ask about the plan, the cost of the plan compared with the cost of replacing key people, and whether succession candidates are developing as expected. If the plan is not having the intended effect, its design, communication, or eligibility may need to change.
Steps to Build a Retention Plan
Identify key roles: Consider which positions would be hardest to replace.
Define your goals: Decide whether the plan is meant to retain, reward performance, or support a transition.
Estimate costs: Model what the plan could cost under different scenarios.
Choose a structure: Compare cash, deferred, and equity-style options.
Document the plan: Work with legal and tax professionals to put terms in writing.
Communicate clearly: Employees value plans they understand.
Review periodically: Business conditions and employee needs change.
Communicating the Plan to Employees
A retention plan is more likely to work if the people it covers understand it. Employees who do not know what they could receive, or when, may not value the plan as much as the owner intended.
Provide a written summary: Explain eligibility, vesting, and how payouts are calculated.
Share periodic statements: Updates on vested and unvested amounts can reinforce the plan's purpose.
Explain what happens in a sale: Employees may want to know how a change in ownership would affect their benefit.
Retention Plans and the Sale of a Business
Buyers often look closely at whether key employees will stay after a transaction. A retention plan that is already in place may help, but buyers will also review how payouts are triggered and who pays them. Some plans accelerate vesting at a sale, while others require the employee to stay for a period afterward. Reviewing these terms before going to market can reduce surprises during negotiations.
How Ballast Advisors Supports Business Owners
Ballast Advisors meets with business owners and their families in Woodbury, St. Paul, and Punta Gorda, and brings 100+ years of combined team experience to its planning work.
Talk Through Your Retention Goals
If a few people are central to your business, a conversation about retention planning can help you consider options that fit your budget and goals.
If you would like a sounding board as you design incentives, let's work together. Schedule a call with a financial planner today.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a key employee retention plan?
It is a compensation arrangement that rewards selected employees for staying with the business over time, often through vesting or performance-based payments.
What are common types of retention plans?
Common types include stay bonuses, deferred bonus plans, nonqualified deferred compensation, phantom stock, stock appreciation rights, and restricted equity.
How is phantom stock different from real equity?
Phantom stock pays a cash benefit tied to company value without giving the employee actual ownership or voting rights.
Are retention bonuses taxable?
Retention payments are generally taxable as wages to the employee when paid or vested, depending on the plan. The business generally deducts them when they are included in the employee's income.
Can a retention plan help with business succession?
It may. Keeping experienced leaders through a sale or family transition can support continuity, and plan terms can be coordinated with succession documents.
This material is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Please consult appropriate professionals before making decisions. The opinions expressed are those of Ballast Advisors, LLC as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. The material presented has been derived from sources considered to be reliable, but accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. There is no guarantee that any strategy will achieve its objectives. Investing involves risks, including possible loss of principal. Asset allocation and diversification may not protect against market risk, loss of principal, or volatility of returns. Registered investment advisors generally owe a fiduciary duty to their advisory clients. Ballast Advisors, LLC is a registered investment advisor under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Supervised persons of Ballast Advisors may act as insurance agents in their individual capacities. Additionally, the firm may recommend Ballast Tax & Business Services LLC, an affiliate of the Firm. Because of the Firm’s relationship with Ballast Tax & Business Services LLC, a conflict of interest exists to the extent that the Firm recommends, or engages, the accounting and tax planning services of Ballast Tax & Business Services LLC. The firm discloses conflicts of interest when clients engage it or its affiliates for compensated services. For more information about conflicts related to our affiliates, please refer to our Form ADV Part 2A Brochure.
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES
The opinions expressed are those of Ballast Advisors, LLC as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. This material is for informational use only and should not be considered investment or financial advice. The material presented has been derived from sources considered to be reliable, but accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed.
Ballast Advisors, LLC is a registered investment advisor under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. More information about the firm, including its services, strategies, and fees can be found in our ADV Part 2 and/or Form CRS, both of which are available without charge upon request. BAL-25-64